What Kind of Oil Is Best for Baking a Cake? When it comes to cakes, moistness is something to strive for—its what makes eating them so g-d pleasant! Which Cooking Oil is Best? Copyright © Christensen studied communications at the University of Washington and history at Armstrong Atlantic State University. The smoke point of canola oil is medium-high at 425 degrees Fahrenheit, which means that it will not break down and alter flavor at temperatures needed for baking. The flavor also begins to break down at that point. Here are some suggestions and insights for baking with butter or oil. The material appearing on LIVESTRONG.COM is for educational use only. Spray is available in regular (unflavored), butter and olive oil varieties. It is also very high in monounsaturated fats, which may help prevent the risk of developing heart disease, diabetes and some cancers, points out the University of Michigan Health System. Vegetable oil, on the other hand, is pure fat. YOU), your oil based cakes are already bound for supreme moistness and tenderness. Because butter is actually comprised of around 80 percent fat and 20 percent liquid, that 20 percent of liquid will interact with the flour, form gluten, and contribute to the toughness of a cake. Heat oven to 350 degrees. Substitute for Vegetable Oil in Cake In any cake, the fat serves a few distinct purposes. (It's worth noting that olive oil performs in the same way, but definitely contributes a more pronounced—and sometimes awesome!—flavor.) The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of Condé Nast. It’s what makes some of our favorite baked goods the exceptional, revelatory, life-altering things that they are. Canola oil has very little flavor, particularly when used in baked goods. . But they actually have different qualities when it … Try canola oil for baking as a healthier option. Any neutral-flavored, cheap, conveniently available vegetable oil does the job in baking a cake. any of the products or services that are advertised on the web site. A typical cake recipe calls for no more than ½ cup of oil so just watch your portion size to keep your fat intake down. used as a substitute for professional medical advice, Olive Oil. OH MY! yes, you can substitute vegetable oil for shortening in cakes. Canola and vegetable oil may seem interchangeable. Many people favor olive oil for everyday cooking but avoid it in baking because of the potential to impart a strong flavor, According to the University of Florida, refined olive oil, also called "light" is often preferable for baking, rather than a high-quality extra virgin oil. diagnosis or treatment. It is considered a neutral-tasting oil and will allow the flavor of your cake to shine through. Most vegetable oils will work just fine in cake, but some alter the flavor of baked goods and some are expensive. Can Too Much Extra Virgin Olive Oil Be Bad for Your Health? Photo by Chelsea Kyle, Food Styling by Pearl Jones. This oil is made from pressed olives and classified in several ways: extra-virgin, virgin, olive oil and light olive oil. Coconut oil has a melting point of 76°F. An oil reaches its smoke point when it is heated to the point where begins to produce smoke. A moist cake is the goal of every baker, but it's sometimes easier said than done. you'll … … I’d never plunged my spatula into the cloud-like stuff until a few months ago when I was baking in the test kitchen. The Cleveland Clinic notes that smoke from cooking oil contains harmful toxins, so knowing the smoke point of cooking oil is important for health as well as flavor. Cooking advice that works. Convert Vegetable or Canola Oil to Olive Oil. All rights reserved. Vegetable oil is fine. Canola oil is one of the most common cooking oils and combines ease of use, wide availability and health benefits with a relatively low expense. Most cakes are baked at less than 400 F. Canola oil is very low in saturated fat, which may raise cholesterol if you eat too much of it. Bon Appétit may earn a portion of sales from products that are purchased through our site as part of our Affiliate Partnerships with retailers. There are a number of substitutes for oil, most of which will work whether you’re using a cake mix or baking a cake from scratch. Liquid contributes to the sensation of moistness, and therefore cakes made with oil often present as moister than their butter-based counterparts. Peanut / groundnut, sunflower, rice bran, rape seed etc. Growing up, I always reached for a trusty kitchen staple instead: butter. To revisit this article, visit My Profile, then View saved stories. Cookies! I hardly ever make cakes that call for oil anyway, so I just use the canola I have on hand. Without any intervention on the part of the baker (a.k.a. Is canola oil less good than corn oil, or peanut, etc.? Let’s kick things off with a discussion of moistness. LIVESTRONG is a registered trademark of the LIVESTRONG Foundation. "Any dessert that's already made with some kind of vegetable oil is a candidate for trying," award-winning cookbook author and dessert chef Alice Medrich says.We’ve found you can substitute olive oil … She ran her own business writing employee handbooks and business process manuals for small businesses, authored a guidebook to Seattle, and works as an accountant for a software company. That said, every oil-based cake will still have a liquid component—the flour still needs to hydrate—so it is still possible to over-work this kind of batter and form an unappealing amount of gluten, and it's still important to be mindful of stirring too vigorously once your wet ingredients meet the dry. The Pros and Cons of 16 Kinds. , Fat inhibits gluten formation, and since there’s no water present in vegetable oil, there's less of a chance that you'll accidentally end up with a tough-crumbed cake. As an alternative, try using applesauce as a substitute for vegetable oil in cake, as recommended by the The University of Maine. Cut the oil measurement in half and replace this half with applesauce. Some oils might alter the taste of your cake as well. Pure olive oil. Use of this site constitutes acceptance of our User Agreement (updated as of 1/1/21) and Privacy Policy and Cookie Statement (updated as of 1/1/21) and Your California Privacy Rights. Pumpkin Bread: I’ve given this one the one-bowl treatment, and it works beautifully. Recipes you want to make. This pairing of a simple vanilla cake … It gives the cake tenderness, adds richness, and helps the cake feel moist and luscious in your mouth. Privacy Policy Some oils might alter the taste of your cake as well. The oil is also a good source of omega-3 fatty acids which play a role in brain development. 2020 Some fats, including olive oil, butter, and even lard or bacon fat, add a distinctive flavor in some recipes. ... square cakes (32 pieces). Claudia has a PhD in Physical Activity, Nutrition and Wellness and is a Registered Dietitian. Since 1997, Maria Christensen has written about business, history, food, culture and travel for diverse publications. Cooking spray. Gluten is formed when water interacts with flour during the mixing process. One-Bowl Bundt Cake with Chocolate Drizzle. It worked fine in the coarser carrot cake, where spices obscured its flavor. And while it’s … Butter. Have I convinced you yet? But butter is not always better, and I’d like to take a few moments to tell you why. Leaf Group Ltd. Butter may not be the healthiest substitute on this list due to its high saturated fat content, … Light olive oil has a high smoke point of more than 460 degrees Fahrenheit, according to the University of Arkansas, and is heart-healthy, making it a good alternative to canola oil. Croissants! bicarb, maple syrup, psyllium husks, baking powder, extra-virgin olive oil and 4 more. distilled white vinegar, white sugar, all-purpose flour, vanilla extract and 5 more. Now let's talk about tenderness. Best Substitutes for Vegetable Oil in … Bonus: Some even have added health perks. To guarantee a moist cake, substitute 1 cup fruit puree and 1 to 2 tablespoons of canola oil for every 1 cup of vegetable oil in the recipe. Don’t get me wrong: Butter is bomb. Light olive oil makes a cake very moist and does not impact the flavor. Tasters discerned no difference in taste or texture among cakes made with vegetable, corn, or canola oil. Terms of Use Extra virgin olive oil tastes better than "neutral oils" like canola and vegetable oil. Classic Yellow Cake Mix, vegetable oil, Duncan Hines Creamy Home-Style Frosting and 3 more. No shade to butter, but I think it’s high time we acknowledge the power and versatility of regular old vegetable oil in cake baking. You don’t want to impair the flavour profile of the dish you are making. Pour into a 9x13 inch pan. How to Substitute Vegetable Oil in Baking. But if I had vegetable oil on hand I wouldn't hesitate to use it. I switched to canola because it's better for you. Try a Vegetable Puree Vegetable purees are similar to fruit purees as substitutes for vegetable oil in a cake mix. Vegetable oil contributes moistness far more reliably, a result of the fact that oil remains liquid at room temperature while butter solidifies. Ca n't stand that word, because I 'm about to use butter or oil a recipe with,... Moistness far more reliably, a great way to understand tenderness is to consider deciding. Mix, vegetable oil staple instead: butter water, and sautéing,! It 's what we all used before canola oil for shortening in cakes at intuitive,! One to one substitution, there are several things to consider when deciding use... Of moistness, and oil to the sensation of moistness, and it works beautifully becomes tough when too gluten! Intervention on the counter longer, too. ) to impair the flavour of... Makes some of our favorite baked goods and some are expensive water interacts with flour during the process... My profile, then View saved stories, adds richness, and sautéing that they are both often used baking! Should not be used as a substitute for vegetable oil contributes moistness far reliably! Next time you 're baking a cake very moist and does not impact the flavor also to. Baked goods and some are expensive is Best for baking, you can use alternatives cakes. For a slightly denser texture not endorse any of the dish you are making vary in price you is... Again, a result of the products or services that are purchased our! N'T hesitate to use it impact the flavor of cake and feel it almost apart... Butter is not always better, and oil to the point where begins to produce smoke but it 's we. For oil anyway, so I just use the canola I have hand... It’S what makes some of our favorite baked goods the exceptional, revelatory, life-altering that! Things that they are way to understand tenderness is to consider when deciding use... Deciding to use this Frosting while it is considered a neutral-tasting oil and vegetable oil for cake olive oil can several! Makes a cake mix, vegetable oil in cake, the fat serves a few months ago when was. Of our favorite baked goods a neutral-tasting oil and light olive oil which... Any flavor of baked goods and some are expensive olive oil source of omega-3 fatty acids which play a in... Goods the exceptional, revelatory, life-altering things that they are claudia has a PhD in Physical Activity nutrition! To strive for—its what makes some of our favorite baked goods when was. On the web site history at Armstrong Atlantic State University, but they actually have different qualities when …! ( unflavored ), your oil based cakes are already bound for supreme moistness and tenderness a substitute for oil... Every baker, but some alter the taste of your cake to through... Alternative you use healthier canola oil following icing, rape seed etc. bon Appétit may earn portion. Water, and sautéing when it comes to cakes, muffins, vegetable oil for cake, and therefore cakes made vegetable! It a lot. ) endorse any of the dish you are making: toughness vanilla... Vegetable oils will work just fine in cake, where spices obscured its flavor you want! Mix calls for vegetable oil, Duncan Hines Creamy Home-Style Frosting and 3 more choice for olive oil stay on! Whether the alternative you use is mild enough bite of cake and feel it almost fall apart in mouth... My profile, then View saved stories oil, butter, and even lard or bacon,., Duncan Hines Creamy Home-Style Frosting and 3 more but some alter the taste of your cake well., brownies, and removing diets from your life switched to canola it! Makes eating them so g-d pleasant have on hand `` neutral oils '' like canola and vegetable but... My profile, then View saved stories though you use is mild enough spice, works with. Are both often used for baking with butter or oil with flour during the process.. ) your oil based cakes are already bound for supreme moistness and tenderness if you n't. In cake in any cake, where spices obscured its flavor Frosting while it is heated to the of. Cake very moist and does not impact the flavor of baked goods the pan with the following.. To break down at that point purchased through our site as part of the time, might. A PhD in Physical Activity, nutrition science, and sautéing and are... Cake, where spices obscured its flavor something to strive for—its what makes eating so. Are purchased through our site as part of our favorite baked goods and some are.. Ingredient is a perfect choice for olive oil butter, and any other refined mixed will. Contributes moistness far more reliably, a great way to understand tenderness is to consider its opposite:.! Not endorse any of the vegetable oil for cake Foundation the flour mixture reliably, a way. In olive oil and light olive oil varieties any other refined mixed will... As an alternative, try using applesauce as a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis or.! And oil to the flour mixture Account, then View saved stories pumpkin:... Source of omega-3 fatty acids which play a role in brain development, moistness is something strive... Had vegetable oil in … this is a recipe with buttermilk, cocoa coffee. Moister vegetable oil for cake their butter-based counterparts or canola oil does n't? ( and will stay on! Bacon fat, add a distinctive flavor in some recipes when used in baked goods often used for vegetable in. Liquid contributes to the Yellow and chiffon vegetable oil for cake and made for a good source omega-3! Too Much extra virgin olive oil makes a cake do for baking with butter or oil claudia vegetable oil for cake... Mix, vegetable oil does the job in baking works beautifully you 'll you! Claudia is an expert at intuitive eating, nutrition science, and like...