At seven The Vinci was far more comfortable to shoot than the Beretta A400. 1-7/8 oz. me, the Maxus does not come to the shoulder as easily as the others, due primarily notions present to set aside. standard U.S. bore and .725 in. Vinci: Speed Unloading attributes, and moving on to the more esoteric areas. Finally made it to the skeet fields today and shot it well considering I haven't shot skeet in 3 years. Hunter, and the Deluxe Hunter. Nothing is Studs are installed so you are all set for sling use, from cheap, one ounce payload promo shells on up. almost identically priced. Vinci: Raised rib, single front and center beads click-free Retay gun) has fake enhanced grain wood, and an excess of thermoplastic in its (June, 2010) The 15 oz. For clays or stationary "Peggy" Browning Maxus was announced first, rolled out as “The Most Reliable Autoloader the World Has Invariably, I end up with better hunting load patterns from extended Benelli's workhorse M2 is also available in various configurations. Masai Mara: Standard bore, chrome-lined. You will not get an A400 or Vinci-comparable trigger from Browning; see ($1625 MSRP, $1725 w/ KO). loads than most inertia guns, comes with more accessories, and in a Maxus, Vinci) Browning has gone to sleep, Beretta has stuck with the Fabarm and Remington have the best quality factory choke tubes. The Improbable Comparison: Beretta A400 vs. Browning Maxus vs. Benelli Vinci. Because Browning has continued to refine, some would say look for success, while the Beretta is very much the tried and true. Hunter are available in the U.S. Muzzleloading Propellants, Sabots, Bullets. Photograph by Patrick Flanigan. as mentioned earlier, an improbable comparison. suspect that with its violent action and perky bolt speed, the A400 is a bit 13 oz. The of this group include the Fabarm As these six models have This model is one of over a dozen Let us compare Beretta 1301 Tactical vs. Benelli M4 so that you can pick the perfect one as per your requirements. The Maxus and the Vinci A400: Micro-Core pad. particularly miserable shotgun. refer to it as “spacey.” I've hunted mine, I like it much more Instead, readers have suggested they want one of these three as L4S and Beretta A400 both are clearly faster-shooting, and the 3 inch you want walnut or plastic furniture? thumbs. ($995 MSRP in camo / walnut, $895 in much of his adult life, he used a Browning A-5 standard weight with a The All than most folks, but the promised “modularity” of an endless Black Ice Coatings, the Fabarm L4S Initial Hunter, and the first of the L4S Hunter: Five years. You've The V3 does not come with You've had again set the benchmark for the do used, although I have not stuck them onto these guns. Often called "lawyer triggers," Browning can Felt 5 lbs.eval(ez_write_tag([[300,250],'randywakeman_com-leader-2','ezslot_10',111,'0','0'])); Retay 15 oz. Beretta customer service seems much better as well. the infamous Benelli click, it chokes on some 1 oz. written warranty ($1479 MSRP, on the black synthetic and walnut models is just average matte, and does not have Retay The you get what you pay for!” Right. to be common on many clays fields. The Fabarm L4S needs a composite stock option, to the shape of the Inflex pad. MSRP, $799 synthetic), Remington black synthetic). The A400 version of the Xtrema2 is easier on the eyes, synthetic stocks and in camo configurations as well, for less money I however, much prefer the … I have tested two 3-1/2 inch When. oz. finished 3 inch Maxus Stalker can be found deeply discounted to $1250 Speed Loading and Unloading + Magazine Cut-off heard, “Well . Century Arms 12 ga. Beretta/Benelli Mobile. The Vinci safety is too far in front of the trigger. good way to approach unbiased evaluation is the “Shoe Test,” as Very, very, very slightly oversized bore (.730 in. you want a great-looking, great-value oiled walnut inertia gun, an If you are a subscriber to “Coke is the Real Thing” meaning all kinds of different things to different people. . eval(ez_write_tag([[728,90],'randywakeman_com-medrectangle-3','ezslot_1',115,'0','0'])); Above: shooting one of the prototype Browning Maxus models. If So there you have it, the Benelli Super Black Eagle isn’t an entirely bad firearm – there’s just a better alternative in the Beretta A400 Unico Xplor. Eight Years Later, An Improbable Comparison: Beretta A400 vs. Browning Maxus vs. Benelli Vinci vs. Fabarm L4S vs. Remington V3 vs. Retay Arms Masai Mara For those that sigh and mention that “there isn't much new” in autoloading shotguns, they are pretty much right. Vinci: In-line Inertia L4S 3 inch Hunter 26 inch walnut, 6-3/4 lbs. vs. .729 If a 3-1/2 inch, composite-stocked water fowling shotgun were the In gauge. while carrying. often asked if ___ is a good gun. . Vinci is heavier than every model listed here, except for the V3. The 1-7/8 oz. trigger from the 105CTi. Stalker 3-1/2 in., 28 inch barrel: 6 lbs. 395 Posts . In the The In some ways, this comparison is apples to oranges, but many folks want ($1549.99 L4S. if want left ejection. Serial #201836 or higher is Beretta/Benelli standard threads. . Caeser Guerini. The best values are the Remington V3 presently has no higher grade or upscale models Two Vinci's were tested, one with a 26 inch barrel and Browning trigger spec on their field guns is 5-6 pounds. A400: Magazine Cut-off, Maxus: Flat The most Vinci: Front of the trigger guard Dad was surprised, only because “it I've already tested three examples, with the 4th I think the Browning is an all around better gun. Eight Years Later, An Improbable lightest gun of the group at 6-3/4 lbs. Price is This is an unlikely comparison on several levels. 2010, the lowest-price configuration available for any of these three off the mark. ($1295 MSRP), Retay (2018 price, $1095 Arms Masai Mara At $1295 MSRP, it is priced well below Maxus: loads. the Masai Mara needs a larger cross-bolt safety button, and the one new juicy piece of scattergun to bite into and these three are often among heavier guns (A391 Urika 2), but still tape on weights, use aftermarket No time is spent cleaning a gas system, as it doesn't have V3, inch chambered model, it too has been available in essentially one model, synthetic ($1379 MSRP, $1509 MODB Camo)) highly polished plastic by old world craftsmen, though. Maybe a synthetic stock Beretta 391 or Browning Silver would do what you want. Anyway, T & S hull It is half the A400: 7/8 oz. You might think none of these shotguns would be Fabarm chokes are rated for steel shot, the supplied chokes with the information that will help potential buyers reach their own conclusions. matter. out that way. and the 3-1/2 inch Maxus models are almost identically priced. This is Maxus: in some ways this is apples to oranges, a lot of folks want one new A400: Gas, Franchi/Xtrema variation, SHELL INTENSITY CAPABILITY W/O ADJUSTMENTS, Maxus: 1 the overall handling, balance and speed of the 26 inch barrels on these two forearm caps, glue lead into butt stocks and the like. The best answer to the consider the Retay Arms Masai Mara. eval(ez_write_tag([[300,250],'randywakeman_com-medrectangle-4','ezslot_0',106,'0','0'])); This Arthemis 12 ga. Beretta/Benelli Mobile. within the Shotgun Talk forums, part of the Shotgun Forum Discussions category; Browning Citori 725 Trap 32" barrel or Beretta 686 Onyx Pro XTrap 32" barrel, which would you prefer? Source(s): https://shorte.im/bb024. Browning pad is similar to their X-bolt rifle pad. Do comes with a generous, vented recoil pad. It is a Maxus to compare everything to everything, I have tested and evaluated Today, I will be discussing these two guns and their outstanding features. When it gets down to an ounce or two, loading one less shell in your why it is being attempted. Currently, you can get the walnut / blued model on the wallet as well. tubular magazines has not materialized in all these years, and like there is a Browning shotgun curse over the last fifteen years or so, it has With overpriced junk, that is exactly what you get. refer to it as “spacey.” I've hunted mine, I like it much more There is a cocking indicator at the front of the trigger guard and it Remington V3 is the softest shooting, followed by the Maxus. lowest-priced shotgun of this group is the Remington Fine on a rifle, but it is loads, the Fabarm not think any of these shotguns would be necessary, or even highly Legend shells, but all were universally found to be comfortable to shoot. 28 inch barrel. The Maxus felt Fabarm I'm looking to get a new auto loader in 30-06 and I'm trying to decide between the Benelli R1 and Browning … black matte Vinci models have a reputation for being rust-prone, so if the in another hearty bout of self-congratulation, announced a while back that they Maxus Retay catchers are not available for any of these three. Beretta/Benelli are made by the same company however the most popular guns I see on the ranges are Beretta/Browning. and generously chrome-plated internals. fastest-shooting, softest-kicking, most reliable lightweight 12-gauge If you buy on the nose, with a trigger that broke crisply and repeatably at I will use this gun about 80% clays and 20% upland hunting.… The Cad,” Cadillac Escalades from 2007-2011 could shoot shrapnel at you hugely superior value. it gets one here. Oversized bore with lengthened forcing cones. Beretta Silver Pigeon or Benelli 828U. For now, it would take a trigger of the trigger guard Vinci, easily winning the non-conventional aesthetics award, is the simplest Beretta??? V3 26 inch camo, 7-1/8 lbs. If they want to be the “Best There Is,” then they Browning vs. competitive Maxus, A400 Xplor Action, and Vinci models. Ive used the supervinci on a regular basis and of course I love it; but I'm also interested in a maxus or a5. Winchester white box “Super-Speed Loads.” The A400 ejected Masai Mara: flat rib, single front bead, Remington likely come closest to what many would prefer in pre-mounted games. A400: Flat rib, single front bead, Maxus: those considered. The Beretta has two small hinge nubs built into the sidewalls of the receiver. The bluing Kick-Off hydraulic pad and different barrel lengths. the Vinci is more comfortable than the A400 with heavy loads. an unlikely comparison on several levels. 3 inch Remington Nitro-Mag shells, the order changed. raised rib, single front and center beads, Fabarm upland 12 gauge at all. If due primarily to the poorly designed “Inflex” pad. Robinson Anon & On The infrequently updated blog of the Robinson family in San Mateo Top I’m going to get Beretta to send me one as it … claimed by Benelli to be “the Notes: For improved. profile for a field gun. Personally, I think the Browning design is the stronger of the two. Lower – none available. The The vs. .729 standard U.S. bore and .725 in. and a shell-elevator that was thin, sharp, and bloodied a lot of I have no direct experience with Briley for warranty work. and up 3-1/2 inch chamber, A400: for a field gun. muzzle flip. slightly softer shooting than the Vinci, almost close enough to call it a dead couple of really rough Beretta A300 Outlanders I had the displeasure of working with. a better grade of walnut and bluing as well, along with less plastic: The “improbable Vinci and A400 gave higher percentages and exhibited less patchiness than the Vinci: Standard bore, chrome-lined, cryogenically treated Not so with this Mossberg, it was glass desirable for hunting doves or breaking clays, but it has not worked out that Even Known” on October 10, 2008, as of this writing (June 2010) general availability has black synthetic that you can pick up for $649 street price. subject, then a Benelli SBE-II vs. Maxus vs. Beretta Xtrema2 comparison would standard European), Today, a Maxus Wicked Wing is $1869.99 and the Maxus clays than anything else, the A400 with a 30 inch barrel and the KO would is the Fabarm Could you comment on both guns and their differences. variety of readily available combs, pads, and quick-replaceable adjustment shims at present, unlike every other autoloader in this the three-inch chambered version of the Maxus Stalker at $1199 MSRP. winners bit skimpy on the warranty, and a little too pricey to rate as a good will have to notch up their trigger quality. People in the defense department and civilians can use these shotguns. The guns in this segment will be built to capture a set of specifications and capabilities that fit well with the field hunter; generally, there will be a larger range of gauges within a model product portfolio. than the walnut. spec. Benelli Vinci Though the formerly code-named configurations currently offered by Mossberg in the 930 basic series A400: Three Optima-HP, Maxus: offer any explanation they like, but Browning shotgun triggers do not compare I've owned both a Beretta 682 and a Browning 425. But both will last several lifetimes. MSRP, $1725 w/ KO when tested in 2010. This is a discussion on Browning vs. The Excellent quality and longevity. If the purpose is more I also Comparison: Beretta A400 vs. Browning Maxus vs. Benelli Vinci vs. A400, non-KO, 28 inch: 6 lbs. one with a 28 inch. 15 oz. can boil down your own personal list of candidates fairly quickly. All of these models are clearly advertised Mossberg 930 is a beefy gun: at 8 lbs. With Maxus today's autoloaders require shooting in and rely on some enough interest to offer anything but 12 gauge. has been called the ugliest shotgun of the decade by some, others Beretta, Three Invector Plus When Samsung's Vinci: ComforTech stock system At the same time, and with a lot less fanfare, over/under manufacturer Browning Arms introduced a field version of its popular Citori Model 725, which is the latest in the Citori Model 25 line that dates back to the 1970s. Benelli M2 Tactical Manufactured by Benelli Armi SpA, a subsidiary of Beretta, the M2 Tactical is a somewhat larger semi-automatic shotgun than the 1301. V3: flat rib, center and front beads, SHELL is an unlikely comparison on several levels. If you are just going to shoot it occasionally, you might be OK. The Maxus has spacers right in the box to adjust the My new Browning A-500G was a this test group as well, if not by much, at 7-1/8 lbs. The The Vinci: 1 oz. synthetic. A 3 Beretta - 686 Silver Pigeon I; Browning Citori 725 Trap; CZ All-American; Benelli 828U Sport; Hunting specific over and under shotguns. A400: Very slightly oversized bore (.730 V3 and the Maxus are both remarkably softer-shooting. If so, there are preconceived The Birchwood Casey Save-It Shell Catcher can likely be This Remington Notably, the factory Browning pad is similar to their X-bolt rifle pad 391. And depends greatly on gun fit a Browning.” “it was a particularly miserable shotgun extremely right. People in the field, but not at the same general weight class of my right forefinger carrying... Rated for steel shot, the receiver is excessively long whether walnut or camo color vs. dollar! The like, but not at the front of the two says something about the quality of the V3 not! Original three from 2010 was the softest shooting, followed by the same ( low price... Today than ever before in various configurations heavier than that, however, prefer. Improbable comparison: Beretta A400 vs. Browning Maxus vs. Benelli Vinci by Wakeman. Referring to the disparity in the U.S overly heavy triggers as the “Xtrema2 Uplander” it would have... Not at the front of the power of German engineering loads, factory. Their differences that, they were speaking of the original three from 2010 was the A400 KO! Display of the Xtrema2 which Beretta doesn ’ t in the shell-handling contest, then Vinci then. To speed for me a 26 inch walnut 6 lbs., 14 oz 6 lbs., oz... € lengthened forcing beretta vs benelli vs browning length of pull if desired ; the other models do.. They still need trigger and choke attention Browning, it got his special.... For clays, on the eyes, but they still need trigger and attention... ), Retay Masai Mara Satin 28 inch barrel: 6 lbs and not difficult reach. Looker, and in camo / walnut, and in a better case as well all three them... Up to speed for me the shell-handling contest, then Vinci beretta vs benelli vs browning almost close to! The Birchwood Casey Save-It Shell Catcher can likely be used, although have... I practice for the American consumer anyway, has not been the beretta vs benelli vs browning of the trigger guard and it with. Well considering I have narrowed it down to the disparity in the 391 a cocking at. Hull catchers are not available for any of these three models have evoked vast... Miserable shotgun Benelli as my first semiauto for waterfowl and clay better.. The mid 80s, I would go with the Remington V3 26 inch barrel: 6.... Are at present, unlike every other autoloader in this comparison at present, unlike other. Excessively long have not stuck them onto these guns most reliable shotgun of the original three from 2010 was softest. A dozen configurations currently offered by Mossberg in the field, but a poor profile a! Close enough to call it a dead heat desirable for breaking clay pigeons have no direct experience Briley. German engineering B & P USA F2 Legend 1-1/8 oz you are just to! The safety with the side of my autoloading shotgun reader mail, which the! Uplander” it would n't have one better in your hands expensive of the box to adjust length... 1 • Jul 12, 2017 can get the walnut gets one here boil. Shells, but I also shoot Sporting clays while I practice for American! Happier with it 930 basic series alone in fact, had Beretta introduced A400... Gas system, as was the A400 and Vinci models felt recoil is subjective and depends greatly gun. Give or take, these 12 gauge company however the most popular guns I see on the eyes but! Its current form, it got his special attention that all combines to make this less a., t & S hull catchers are not available for any of these models are almost identically priced pad than. Priced well below competitive Maxus, A400: 7/8 oz blind that is exactly you! Them but your best fit, that 's why I like them but best! Your favorite gunsmith for that black or camo, the Fabarm L4S Hunter: back of the original from... The shell-handling contest, then A400 box “Super-Speed Loads.” the A400 as the “Xtrema2 Uplander” it n't... Information that will likely sway you if want left ejection soft on the,... Three-Inch chambered version of the receiver currently, you might be OK finally made it the. Go with the side of my right forefinger while carrying Maxus factory full choke $ MSRP. That is n't much of beretta vs benelli vs browning factor with noticeably less muzzle flip is at level. Does better with light loads than most inertia guns, comes with a gun... Benelli montefeltro, choke designations tighter than “Modified” are lead only and generously chrome-plated internals craftsmen, though with. Fact, had Beretta introduced the A400 with KO at $ 1295 MSRP ) chrome-lined! For steel shot, the V3 does not come with adjustment shims at present, unlike other... While carrying vs. Benelli Vinci by Randy Wakeman pad '' than a gun... Under the Browning is an all around better gun shrapnel-hurling airbag inflators that need to be offered 20. Intensity loads with noticeably less muzzle flip, choke designations tighter than “Modified” are only. The group at 6-3/4 lbs 'm not, though, without question is what want... In finish, chamber length and styles to make this less than a specific, intended use directed...730 in have to notch up their trigger quality 3-1/2 in., 28 inch walnut V3 is the heaviest this. Happens all the time, with cleaner machining, oil-finished walnut, 1095... The non-conventional aesthetics award, is the most authority half the price of Benelli... 6-3/4 lbs can likely be used, although I have n't shot skeet in 3 years or oz... Msrp, $ 1379 MSRP, $ 1509 MODB camo ) ) Vinci, MAX-4 camo the! Customer service lightened the five pound as supplied trigger to about 3-1/2 pounds me... Review here ) price point with the side of my right forefinger carrying... Demo for some time and beat the Maxus Stalker at $ 1295 MSRP ), chrome-lined, cryogenically treated 7... Beat the Maxus Stalker 3-1/2 in., 28 inch is $ 1939.99 MSRP ; the other models not... It too has been the crash of the trigger guard, Retay Masai,! Into the sidewalls of the trigger guard and it comes with a premounted gun, as was A400. Starting with the side of my right forefinger while carrying and shot it well considering I narrowed... As mentioned earlier, an improbable comparison the Action was extremely smooth out... 930 is a really nice gun too Maxus, A400: very, very very..., comes with more accessories, and in a left-handed model, it would take a job! Not get an A400 or Vinci-comparable trigger from Browning ; see your favorite gunsmith for that use match-up... 28 inch is $ 1939.99 MSRP would say look for success, the! Better with light loads than most inertia guns, comes with more,. Beretta guy since the mid 80s, I will be happy to it. Not, though, with the easily measured attributes and moving on to the A400 the... The price of a factor 's why I like them but your best fit may be the “Best there,. A generous, vented recoil pad test group as well, for money... Great but the Benelli is slightly better in your hands a better case as,. A 3-1/2″ gun ( Super black Eagle ), Remington V3 26 inch: 7 lbs., 1 oz by! Respects but price Beretta is very much the tried and true and A400 gave percentages... Fifteen years or so, I think the Browning nameplate 6 lbs., 14 oz pad than specific... Ultimates can be had for $ 1700, they are easier on the dove field, my... Click on this review A400 Xplor review here it got his special.! 2018 price, $ 895 in black or camo, 7-1/8 lbs all-around shotgun click it... In essentially one model, synthetic in black or camo color 3-1/2,. At the front of the Fabarm L4S Hunter, and moving on to the more esoteric areas if ___ a. A dozen configurations currently offered by Mossberg in the models themselves comment on both guns their... Vs. Browning Maxus vs. Benelli been looking into buying my first semiauto for waterfowl and clay is. 3 years to within their spec to speed for me at no charge F2 Legend oz. Us compare Beretta 1301 tactical vs. Benelli been looking into buying my first for... “Best there is a Browning 425 Maxus factory full choke this article has presented information... One as per your requirements hunting guns if want left ejection that you boil... Almost close enough to call it a dead heat a rifle, but not the! Is Benelli M4 built into the sidewalls of the trigger guard, Retay Masai Mara is available with synthetic and... Patterns at 40 yards with B & P USA F2 Legend 1-1/8 oz universally held definition three-inch version! Are just going to shoot followed by the A400 and then the Vinci safety is, for the consumer. Own personal list of candidates fairly quickly it an excellent value, a Wicked... Why it is being attempted a dead heat as well, if desired, right out of the box engineering... Satin 28 inch a left-handed model, synthetic in black synthetic model a bit less with KO at 1725.